Journal of Oceanology and Limnology   2019, Vol. 37 issue(3): 871-880     PDF
Institute of Oceanology, Chinese Academy of Sciences

Article Information

DIN Siti Sabariah, CHEW Kit Wayne, CHANG Yu-Kaung, SHOW Pau Loke, PHANG Siew Moi, JUAN Joon Ching
Extraction of agar from Eucheuma cottonii and Gelidium amansii seaweeds with sonication pretreatment using autoclaving method
Journal of Oceanology and Limnology, 37(3): 871-880

Article History

Received May. 15, 2018
accepted in principle Aug. 1, 2018
accepted for publication Sep. 3, 2018
Extraction of agar from Eucheuma cottonii and Gelidium amansii seaweeds with sonication pretreatment using autoclaving method
DIN Siti Sabariah1,5, CHEW Kit Wayne1, CHANG Yu-Kaung2, SHOW Pau Loke1, PHANG Siew Moi3,4, JUAN Joon Ching5     
1 Department of Chemical and Environmental Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, University of Nottingham Malaysia, Jalan Broga, Semenyih 43500, Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia;
2 Department of Chemical Engineering, Ming Chi University of Technology, New Taipei, Taiwan 24301, China;
3 Institute of Ocean and Earth Sciences, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur 50603, Malaysia;
4 Institute of Biological Sciences, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur 50603, Malaysia;
5 Nanotechnology & Catalysis Research Centre, Institute of Postgraduate Studies, University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur 50603, Malaysia
Abstract: The effect of sonication pretreatment condition on Eucheuma cottonii and Gelidium amansii seaweed towards agar extraction wae studied. Four parameters were changed during sonication to investigate the effects on agar yield and quality. These parameters include the time interval, concentration ratio, frequency, and intensity. The highest amount of agar extracted from Eucheuma cottonii species could be obtained from the time interval of 30 min, seaweed weight to solvent volume ratio of 1:20, the frequency of 35 Hz, and the sonication power intensity of 30%. For Gelidium amansii species, the best agar yield also could be obtained from the time interval of 30 min, 1:20 of seaweed weight to water volume ratio, the frequency of 35 Hz, and power intensity of 30%. From the experiment, sonication pretreatment significantly influenced the yield and properties of extracted agar. The sonication with autoclaved seaweed produced agar containing less sulfate content, which is an excellent chemical property for gel electrophoresis applications. The gel strength of sonication with autoclaving for both seaweeds, Eucheuma and Gelidium species was the highest among those by sonication with direct heating, which proved that sonication pretreatment with autoclaving could enhance the physical properties of the agar.
Keywords: Gelidium amansii    Eucheuma cottonii    autoclaving    sonication pretreatment    water extraction    

Agars are derived from marine macroalgae, particularly red seaweeds. They contain strong gelling polysaccharides and linear polymers can be characterized by its chemically repeating units of 3-6, anhydro L-galactose and alternating D-galactose bond (Francavilla et al., 2013). The structure of agar comprises two separate polymers that can be fractionated. One of them is agarose, which has better gelling properties, and the other is agaropectin, which is the non-gelling sulfated fraction (Nishinari and Fang, 2017). Red seaweed can also peculiarly produced sulfated galactans, which consist of sulfate esters in very low levels and some methoxy groups (Recalde et al., 2016). However, the pattern of sulfate groups and the type of glycosidic linkage in the polysaccharides differ among the species.

Agars are widely used for various applications, which include food industry, dentistry, bacteriological and biotechnological uses (Hernández-Carmona et al., 2013; Abdul Khalil et al., 2018). In the food industry, agars are used as a gelling and thickening agent, where the gelling properties of agars are used as a stabilizer in acidic dairy products. In the dentistry and biotechnology application, derivatives of agars can be used as dental prosthetics, molding of materials, and plant culture tissues (Chew et al., 2018a; Ouyang et al., 2018). There are three categories of algae: red algae, brown algae (Phaeophyceae) and green algae (Chlorophyceae) (Abdul Khalil et al., 2018). Brown macroalgae consist of practically 1 800 species, with an olive-green to dark brown color derived from an abundance of fucoxanthin. This type of macroalgae consumes a yellow-brown pigment that masks the green color of chlorophyll. Green algae contain approximately 1 500 species all over the world, which are mainly used as a starch in the food industry due to the capability of the polysaccharides structures containing cellulose and pectin. Meanwhile, for red algae, they consist of 6 000 species, which commonly grow in deep waters. Red algae were specifically called as red due to the phycocyanin and phycoerythrin pigments present in this marine macroalgae type (Fuse and Goto, 1971). Additionally, the composition of red algae imitates their species, which contains cellulose, glucan, and galactan. Two types of structural polysaccharides that are useful in gel formation can be found in these algae, which are carrageenan and agar. The red alga Gelidium amansii, is mainly used for agar extraction, due to its high quality of agars to be extracted and the compositions contained in these type of species (Hernández-Carmona et al., 2013). While for Eucheuma cottonii (Kappaphycus Alvarezii), they are commonly used for carrageenan extraction (Distantina et al., 2011). These types of macroalgae obtained a high yield of carrageenan on previous studies (Loureiro et al., 2010; Chan et al., 2013; Recalde et al., 2016). To date, however, none of the researchers has studied the structures of these macroalgae. Therefore, one of the objectives of this study was to investigate and study the presence of agar structures and their properties in Eucheuma cottonii species compared than Gelidium amansii species.

There are various of methods that have been developed and currently being used by the industries to produce agar, such as an eco-friendly agar extraction method called agar photobleaching extraction process (Li et al., 2008). In their study, the photo-bleached agar gelling temperature means that the temperature is within the acceptable range of the international market. They also discover that the photolysis process used by them was useful for sulfate group removal with alkaline hydrolysis while increasing the gel strength of agar that produced during the photolysis (Li et al., 2008). Recently, the optimization and quality of agar polysaccharide isolated from the marine red macroalgae Pyropia yezoensis by using alkaline pretreatment have been studied (Sasuga et al., 2017). It was claimed that alkaline pretreatment of agar extraction process helps the conversion of L-galactose sulfate to 3, 6-anhydrogalactose, by increasing their average molecular weight. Alkali-pretreated agar also contains less sulfate content and higher gel strength values than that of native agar. Therefore, their study proved that alkaline pretreatment for Pyropia yezoensis species could produce industrial grade agar comparable to that by Gelidium species (Sasuga et al., 2017).

Nowadays, most of the currently used methods are green and safe to the environment, apart from being efficient and suitable for an industry used (Li et al., 2008). However, some of the methods used require long processing time, complicated operation, and using harsh chemicals. This creates the need for some innovation on the processing of agar to improve the quality and yield of agar extracted, whereby the utilization of an advanced pretreatment technology that could improve the extraction of agar would benefit the overall economics of agar processing (Chew et al., 2018b). The traditional process of agar extraction involves steps like alkali-treated seaweeds in an extraction solution, filtration of the extract, and jellification, freezing, thawing, and drying etc. Therefore, the extraction methods can thus vary in terms of the type and parameter used to get various properties of the agar-extracted product (Souza et al., 2012).

In this study, agar was extracted from the red macroalga Eucheuma cottonii species, and then was compared to existing agar sources of Gelidium amansii in terms of the yield, and physical and chemical properties of the resulting agar. On the other hand, we focused on the effect of autoclaving in ultrasonic pretreatment to extract agar from both red macroalgae species. Agar was subsequently extracted using the eco-friendly and simple method. The effects of different sonication pretreatment parameters used on agar extraction were evaluated where the parameters include (time interval, frequency, intensity, and concentration). Our study was done to verify the feasibility of agar extraction by applying sonication pretreatment with autoclaving method proposed. The No.3 DIN et al.: Sonication pretreatment for agar extraction 873 comparison of agar yield and quality for both seaweeds are further discussed.


Two types of red macroalgaes, Gelidium amansii, and Eucheuma cottonii, were used. The seaweeds were collected in South Korea (33°6′–43°0′N / 124°11′–131°50′E). The samples were washed thoroughly with clean water and dried using the airdrying oven (Memmert, Germany) for 3 to 4 days at 50℃. The samples were peeled into smaller pieces and stored in dry place for further experiments. HCl, K2SO4, H2SO4 and other chemicals were obtained from R & M Chemicals (Malaysia).

2.2 Method 2.2.1 Synthesis of agar

Agar extraction was performed as per Mollet et al. (1998). The seaweeds were extracted by using a water extraction method, with a water ratio of 1:20 to 1:30 [w/v] (Mollet et al., 1998). In brief, the pH of the solution was adjusted to 6.0–6.5 using 0.002 5% H2SO4 solution and measured using a pH meter (Sartorius, model PB-10). Then, pretreatment was operated by using an ultrasonic processor (Hielscher, UP400S) fitted with a standard sonotrodes H3, in which the process was divided into two conditions, (ⅰ) sonication pretreatment with autoclaving; and (ⅱ) sonication pretreatment with direct heating. The parameters used for sonication are shown in Table 1. All experiments were performed at room temperature.

Table 1 Condition of sonication pretreatment process

The hot water extraction after the sonication was divided into two conditions: using direct heating (Fisher Scientific, hotplate stirrer) and autoclaving. For direct heating, the temperature used was 99℃ for 1.5 h, while for autoclaving, the temperature used was 120℃ for 1 h. After the extraction, the seaweed solution was filtered to remove insoluble particles from the aqueous solution by using filter cloth and cellulose nitrate membrane filtration (3 μm). The filtrate was then allowed to cool down to ambient temperature, and being frozen overnight at -20℃. Thereafter, the solution was thawed at room temperature and was subjected to centrifugation (5 500 r/min, 15 min) to separate the water content and desired agar mixture. This separation step was important to obtain the pure agar content. Then, the mixture was oven dried (VO200-Memmert, Germany) at 50–60℃ for 2 or 3 days until a constant weight was obtained. The dried agar sample was weighed and recorded.

2.2.2 Characterization of agar

The structural characterization of agar was carried out in Fourier Transmission Infrared Spectroscopy FTIR (Perkin Elmer, Germany). The characterization was conducted in order to observe the purity and chemical bonding of the agar structures. The frequency range was between 4 000–400 cm-1. The resolution used is 4 cm-1, which is 8 times of scanning rate. The force gauge chosen for agar characterization was between 80–100 N.

2.2.3 Measurement of gelling and melting temperatures

Gelling and melting temperatures of the agar samples were measured as described by Wang et al. (2017), with some modifications (Wang et al., 2017). For gelling temperature, 5 mL of hot agar solution (2.0% w/v) was prepared in a 50-mL test tube. The agar solution was cooled at a rate of 0.5–1.0℃/min. At the same time, a thermometer was placed in the hot agar solution to record the temperature. The test tube containing the agar solution was slanted by 45° and returned back to the vertical position, for each 0.5℃ drop in temperature. The gelling temperature was obtained when the surface of the agar solution does not go back to its horizontal position and was completely congealed.

While for the melting temperature, 5 mL of agar gel (2.0% w/v) was prepared in a 10-mL test tube. The sample was placed at room temperature and kept overnight, covered with aluminum foil. An iron ball of 4 mm diameter was placed on the surface of the agar gel. The sample was submerged into a beaker containing water and placed on a hotplate with adjustable heat. The range of temperature adjusted to reach 100℃ (with a gradual increase of 1℃/min). The melting temperature was recorded when the iron ball touched the bottom of the test tube.

2.2.4 Measurement of agar gel strength

Gel strength of agar was measured by using a TAXT plus texture analyzer (Stable Micro Systems Ltd., Surrey, UK). The agar gel was prepared by using 2.0% (w/v) of agar gel with gel depth approximately 15–20 mm in a test tube. The agar gel was placed at room temperature and left overnight. The 75 mm diameter cylindrical plunger p/75 probe was used for analysis, with a 5 000-g load cell and the penetration speed of 1 mm/s for a distance of 5 mm. The gel strength was measured and expressed in g/cm2.

2.2.5 Quantification of sulfate content

Sulfate content was measured as per Yarnpakdee et al. (2015), in which BaCl2-gelatin reagent was used immediately after HCl hydrolysis. Firstly, agar powder (40 mg) was hydrolyzed at 105–110℃ with 6 mL of 0.5 mol/L HCl solution. Then, the solution was mixed and filtered using Whatman No. 1 filter paper (0.22 μm). Next, 0.2 mL of solution was transferred into a 10-mL test tube containing 3.8 mL of trichloroacetic acid, TCA (3%w/v) and 1-mL BaCl2-gelatin reagent. The solution was mixed and left at room temperature for 20 min. Sample blank was prepared, except the distilled water was used instead of the agar sample. The absorbance at 360 nm was measured using a UV-Vis spectrophotometer (Shimadzu, model UV-1800). Finally, the sulfate content was measured and expressed by a standard curve prepared using solutions of K2SO4 in concentration from 0.1 to 1.0 mg/mL (0.053 3– 0.533 mg/SO4/mL) as a reference.

3 RESULT 3.1 Characterization of Agar

Agar was successfully characterized by using the FTIR spectra as shown in Fig. 1. Two types of agars that extracted from Gelidium amansii and Eucheuma cottonii have gone through sonication pretreatment in autoclaving were successfully studied. For Gelidium seaweed, strong absorption peaks can be seen at 3 252.68 cm-1, 1 646.07 cm-1, 1 373.26 cm-1, and 921.68 cm-1. While for Eucheuma, high absorption peaks were shown at 3 273.03 cm-1, 1 645.6 cm-1, 1 373.15 cm-1, and 920.66 cm-1. These peaks represent specific chemical bonding and vibration resulted from the agar structures. Both seaweeds showed higher absorption bands at range 920–921 cm-1, while less vibration occurred at the range of 1 373.15 cm-1 and 1 373.26 cm-1.

Fig.1 FTIR spectra of extracted agar from Gelidium amansii and Eucheuma cottonii species
3.2 Effect of frequency on agar yield

The agar yield obtained is shown in Fig. 2. The overall agar yield was calculated based on the percentage of dry weight. In overall, Fig. 2 shows that the value of the highest agar yield occurred at frequency 35 Hz for both Gelidium and Eucheuma species by sonication pretreatment with autoclaving, which was 6.78% and 38.06%, respectively. The lowest agar yield for Gelidium and Eucheuma species was obtained when the frequency was 130 Hz, which as 3.76% and 15.75%, respectively.

Fig.2 Agar yield obtained from two types of seaweed in two different frequencies The yield is expressed as a percentage of dry weight.
3.3 Effect of seaweed weight to water volume ratio on agar yield

Figure 3 shows the effect of seaweed weight to water volume ratio on agar yield produced. The highest agar yield for Eucheuma cottonii seaweed was 59.47%, which obtained from 1:20 ratio by sonication pretreatment with autoclaved agar, where the lowest agar yield from the same species was 0.88%, which was obtained from 1:12 ratio by sonication pretreatment with direct heating agar. For Gelidium amansii seaweed, 1:20 ratio at sonication pretreatment with autoclaving showed the highest agar yield compared than 1:12 ratio at sonication pretreatment with direct heating, which was 8.77% and 4.16%, respectively.

Fig.3 Agar yield obtained from the different ratio of seaweed weight and water volume used The yield is expressed as a percentage of dry weight.
3.4 Effect of time on agar yield

Figure 4 shows the effect of time interval on agar yield. For Eucheuma cottonii species, the highest value of agar yield was at 30 min time interval by sonication pretreatment with autoclaving while the lowest at 45 min time interval of sonication pretreatment with direct heating, which was 52.70% and 10.37%, respectively. Whereas for Gelidium amansii species, the highest value of agar yield was at 30 min time interval by sonication pretreatment with autoclaving and the lowest at 15 min of sonication pretreatment with direct heating, which was 8.70% and 4.45%, respectively.

Fig.4 Agar yield obtained from different time interval for two types of seaweeds that sonication-pretreated with autoclaving and with direct heating The yield is expressed as a percentage of dry weight.
3.5 Effect of power intensity on agar yield

Figure 5 showed the power intensity on agar yield produced. Based on the results, the highest value was 41.58% of power intensity, 30% for sonicated Eucheuma cottonii species while the lowest value was 4.22% of power intensity, 90% for sonicated Gelidium amansii species. For Eucheuma species, the trend of the agar yield was decreasing as the intensity increased, which were 41.58%, 22.02% and 12.02% for the power of 30, 60, and 90, respectively. As for Gelidium species, the agar yield for the power of 30, 60, and 90 were slightly different, which were 4.73%, 4.53%, and 4.22%, respectively.

Fig.5 Agar yield obtained from two types of seaweed used with different values of intensity The yield is expressed as a percentage of dry weight.
3.6 Optimization condition

The agar yields depend on physical and chemical properties, such as gelling strength, gelling and melting temperature, and sulfate content. The optimization conditions for agar yield are shown in Table 2. For Gelidium amansii species, the yield for sonication pretreatment with autoclaved agar showed a higher value than that of sonication pretreatment with direct heating, being 49.10% and 13.26%, respectively. For Eucheuma species, the yield for sonication pretreatment with autoclaving was 56.49%, which is higher than that of sonication with direct heating for about 16.02%.

Table 2 The optimization results obtained from two types of seaweeds, where the yield is expressed as a percentage of dry weight

In Table 2, the gel strength values of each condition are in different ranges. Consequently, agars from Eucheuma and Gelidium species by sonication pretreatment with autoclaving showed the highest values than those with direct heating, which was 190 g/cm2 and 840 g/cm2, respectively. For sonication pretreatment with direct heating, the values for Eucheuma and Gelidium were 17 g/cm2and 390 g/cm2, respectively. Meanwhile, for gelling and melting temperature of both seaweeds tested, the values ranged from 26.9℃ to 25.2℃ and from 51.4℃ to 68.0℃, respectively. Where for the sulfate content, according to the results, all the samples attained with almost similar sulfate content (0.477 5 to 0.301 3 mg/mL). The sulfate contents of sonication pretreatment with autoclaving for Eucheuma and Gelidium species were quite low, for 0.301 3 and 0.310 8 mg/mL, while that of sonication with direct heating was 0.477 5 and 0.417 4 mg/mL, respectively.

4 DISCUSSION 4.1 Characterization of agar

As shown in Fig. 1, agar extracted from Gelidium amansii species showed a high peak absorption at 1 373.26 cm-1, which is due to the sulfate ester (S=O group) vibration. For the vibration peak at 3 252.68 cm-1, it was caused by the interaction of the oxygen atom of OH groups of D-galactopyranose. Thereafter, the other chemical groups for the characteristics of a given agar type, namely 3, -6-anhydro-L-galactopyranose at 921.68 cm-1 and carbonyl group (C=O stretching) were observed at 1 646.07 cm-1. On the other hand, the FTIR spectra of Eucheuma cottonii agar showed a very strong beam absorption in the region 3 273.03 cm-1 (for OH stretching of the hydroxyl group) and 1 645.6 cm-1 region (C=O stretch peak). The agar extracted from Eucheuma cottonii, showed a strong absorption band in the region 1 373.15 cm-1, which was caused by the sulfate ester (S=O groups) vibration. Gómez-Ordóñez and Rupérez (2011) stated that the peaks produced are correlated to the agar quality, and the presence of α-Lgalactose, -6-sulfate units may lessen the gel strength of the polygalactans. Whereas, both of the agar products displayed high peaks at 920.66 cm-1, reflecting the vibration of the C-O-C bridge of 3, 6-anhydro-L-galactopyranose. This C-O-C group band is the utmost representative of the agar structure because infrared spectra of other polysaccharides contained in red macroalgae like cellulose and xylans would not be observed at this wave range. This band is also associated with the degree of sulphatation, due to the 1, 4-linked residue that may be replaced by 3, 6-anhydro-L-galactose residue or be switched by other sulfate groups (Stanley, 1995).

4.2 Effect of frequency on agar yield

The data (Fig. 2) show that the agar yield of sonication pretreatment with autoclaving was higher than those of direct heating. Previously, Fidelis et al. (2014) studied the effect of sonication frequency and enzymatic proteolysis, as well as an alkaline pretreatment on chemical composition, structure, and antioxidant activity of sulfated polysaccharides extracted from Glacilaria birdiae. They found that sonication frequency at a lower value as well as alkali treatment done on seaweed was the best condition to extract anticoagulant and antioxidant sulfated polysaccharides from Glacilaria birdiae. The high yield at 35 Hz is related to changes in agar structures, thus allowing the release of most polysaccharides when extracted at this frequency. In other words, the intracellular hydrogen bonding in polysaccharides can be devastated due to trivial frequency waves, thus altering the structures.

4.3 Effect of seaweed to water ratio on agar yield

As seen in Fig. 3, the highest agar yield was at ratio 1:20 for both seaweeds Gelidium and Eucheuma, where ratios 1:60 and 1:12 were low in agar yield, which is because, at the ratio of 1:12, the smaller weight ratio caused a low agar yield due to lack of volume of water available to extract the agar from the raw seaweed. These results indicated that small amount of solvent used for polysaccharide extraction will cause the diffusion driving force to become small and difficult to spread, hence slowing down the agar extraction process (Kumar and Fotedar, 2009). While the increase of water volume can result in less agar yield. Therefore, both of the seaweed species that affected by the sonication pretreatment with autoclaving could increase the agar yield. On the other hand, the effect of seaweed-water ratio during agar extraction process on agar properties was studied instead of the seaweed-water ratio used during pretreatment process (Arvizu-Higuera et al., 2008; Orduña-Rojas et al., 2008). Based on their results, the greater the volume of water, the easier the agar to be extracted. Dried seaweed can surge to about 20 times of their dry matter volume when exposed to water. Among the three values of seaweed to water ratio, 1:20 of both seaweeds showed the highest agar yield, indicating the suitable ratio for agar extraction condition.

4.4 Effect of time on agar yield

Seen from Fig. 4, the effect of time interval on agar yield produced from Gelidium and Eucheuma seaweeds is shown. The purpose of the time setting for pretreatment is to hydrate the seaweeds and promote the accessibility of soluble polysaccharides. The main constituents of seaweeds are polysaccharides as a hydrophilic polymer. Hydrogen bonding was used for water and polysaccharides of seaweeds reaction, in which the water-holding capacity of seaweeds varies in each species used. Time parameters have a gradual effect on Gelidium amansii agar yield, but for Eucheuma cottonii species, had mostly affected the agar yield. This can be seen in the results at a time interval of 30 min, agar yield increased drastically from sonication pretreatment with direct heating to sonication pretreatment with autoclaving, which was also the optimum time interval for a higher agar yield (Ahmad et al., 2011). Our best result for time interval was 30 min but 45 min, which is the same, the best time interval. It is because, at a higher time interval, biopolymer degradation may occur in the yield of agar. A longer time would affect the sulfate-binding process by alkaline materials. In addition, the longer pretreatment time (45 min) could result in diffusion between agar and water and lowered the yields, as agar structures were altered when sulfate was one of the important parts of agar molecular chains (Orduña-Rojas et al., 2008).

4.5 Effect of power intensity on agar yield

The effect of power intensity on agar yield produced is shown in Fig. 5. The agar yield of seaweeds Gelidium and Eucheuma showed that the power intensity affected the yield produced, especially for Eucheuma species. It can be seen that as the intensity increased, the yield of Eucheuma species decreasing drastically. On the other hand, the agar yield of Gelidium species decreased on a small scale when the intensity increased gradually. It can be explained that the effect of sonication on agar extraction yield was attributed to the collapsing bubble and cavitation that tempted the stress on the cell wall of macroalgae structure. This is because, during sonication pretreatment, the prompts of cell interference caused ultrasonic waves. Arvizu-Higuera et al. (2008) mentioned that high-intensity ultrasonic waves would cause a small trembling collapse of cavitation bubbles between agar cells (Arvizu-Higuera et al., 2008). This can be explained why the agar yields of the two seaweeds decreased with the power intensity increase. To the best of our knowledge, power intensity may affect agar yield because the mechanical and chemical energy catastrophic processes throughout the cell wall could release intracellular compounds into solution, and produced the emission of shockwaves. This explanation gains support from Bleakley and Hayes (2017); they stated that the cavitational effect in sonication might enhance the extraction of chemical compounds from macroalgae, which was done by facilitating solvent access through cell disruption and proper mass transfer during the sonication process in a high power intensity.

4.6 Optimization conditions

The agar yields and the physical and chemical properties for the optimization conditions are shown in Table 2. The proficiency of agar produced for food industry application depends on its capability in forming a thermoreversible gel. Therefore, gelling and melting temperatures are significantly important in agar quality control (Stanley, 1995). From the present study, the gelling temperature (25.2–26.9℃) is the standard range used in biotechnology applications. Previously, Oyieke (1993) obtained a similar gelling temperature (27.1℃) as reported using other species, Glacilaria gracilis. Intracellular hydrogen bonding in polysaccharides can be devastated due to the trivial frequency waves that could cause fluctuation of the structures, which explained the gelling temperature of sonication pretreatment with autoclaving was higher than that of direct heating. In previous studies, it was reported that the gelling temperature increased as the increase of methoxyl content (Duckworth and Yaphe, 1971; Andriamanantoanina et al., 2007). However, some other studies on different seaweeds used applied higher gelling temperatures for G. tenuistipitata (42.3℃) and G. arcuata (63.5℃) (Montaño et al., 1999). These authors explained that the high gelling temperature of G. arcuata is uncommon and was likely due to the colloids' high molecular weight. Meanwhile, the melting temperature of the two seaweeds we tested, the values ranged from 51.4℃ to 68.0℃. The maximum melting temperature obtained (68.2℃) in the present study is similar to that of G. blodgetti (Bird and Hinson, 1992).

For Eucheuma species, the agar yield for sonication pretreatment with autoclaving was higher than that with direct heating. For Gelidium species, the agar yield for sonication pretreatment with autoclaving was higher than that with direct heating. This shows that sonication-autoclaving pretreatment yielded a better quality of agar than non-autoclaving sonicated agar. The gel produced was also very clear and transparent. The gel strength values of each condition were in different ranges (Table 2). As a result, agars of sonication pretreatment with autoclaving of the two seaweeds, Eucheuma and Gelidium species showed the greater values than those by direct heating. The higher extraction of agarose composition indicates the greater ability to separate agarose from agaropectin in the pretreatment process. Improvement in terms of high gelling extraction can be done in the future to enhance the gelling strength. While for the sulfate content, according to the results, all the samples attained with a very small range (0.301 3–0.477 5 mg/mL). The sulfate contents of agar by autoclaving for both Eucheuma and Gelidium species were quite low than those by direct heating. The values obtained are within the range of standard values for both tests, which means that the chemical composition of the agars was suitable for the industry, especially the food industry (Recalde et al., 2016). Higher sulfate content of agars can affect the gel strength as well as the agar yield as reported in some studies (Navarro et al., 2007; Arvizu-Higuera et al., 2008). In these studies, the increase of sulfate content could be related to the changes in the molecular structures of the agar. Therefore, it was successfully proved that sonication pretreatment with autoclaving is able to reduce sulfate content in the agar gels produced.


In conclusion, we successfully studied the properties of Eucheuma cottonii seaweed with Gelidium amansii and compared them in terms of their yield percentage of agar, and their physical and chemical properties. The results show that Eucheuma had a higher yield of agar than Gelidium species after sonication pretreatment with autoclaving. Eucheuma cottonii can produce a high yield of agar, featuring low sulfate content, good gelling, and higher melting temperatures (65–68℃). The optimal conditions of sonication pretreatment with autoclaving are: time interval of 30 min, power intensity of 30%, seaweed to water ratio of 1:20 w/v, and the frequency of 35 Hz. Improvement in using a different range of parameters during the pretreatment process will be realized to enhance the physical properties of agar production in near future.


The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.


The final version was edited and polished by Dr. Roger Z. YU.

Abdul Khalil H P S, Lai T K, Tye Y Y, Rizal S, Chong E W N, Yap S W, Hamzah A A, Nurul Fazita M R, Paridah M T. 2018. A review of extractions of seaweed hydrocolloids:properties and applications. eXPRESS Polymer Letters, 12(4): 296-317. DOI:10.3144/expresspolymlett.2018.27
Ahmad R, Surif M, Ramli N, Yahya N, Nor A R M, Bekbayeva L. 2011. A preliminary study on the agar content and agar gel strength of Gracilaria manilaensis using different agar extraction processes. World Applied Sciences Journal, 15(2): 184-188.
Andriamanantoanina H, Chambat G, Rinaudo M. 2007. Fractionation of extracted Madagascan Gracilaria corticata polysaccharides:structure and properties. Carbohydrate Polymers, 68(1): 77-88. DOI:10.1016/j.carbpol.2006.07.023
Arvizu-Higuera D L, Rodríguez-Montesinos Y E, Murillo-Álvarez J I, Muñoz-Ochoa M, Hernández-Carmona G. 2008. Effect of alkali treatment time and extraction time on agar from Gracilaria vermiculophylla. Journal of Applied Phycology, 20(5): 515-519. DOI:10.1007/s10811-007-9258-4
Bird K T, Hinson T K. 1992. Seasonal variations in agar yields and quality from North Carolina agarophytes. Botanica Marina, 35(4): 291-295.
Bleakley S, Hayes M. 2017. Algal proteins:extraction, application, and challenges concerning production. Foods, 6(5): 33. DOI:10.3390/foods6050033
Chan S W, Mirhosseini H, Taip F S, Ling T C, Tan C P. 2013. Comparative study on the physicochemical properties of κ-carrageenan extracted from Kappaphycus alvarezii(doty) doty ex Silva in Tawau, Sabah, Malaysia and commercial κ-carrageenans. Food Hydrocolloids, 30(2): 581-588. DOI:10.1016/j.foodhyd.2012.07.010
Chew K W, Juan J C, Phang S M, Ling T C, Show P L. 2018a. An overview on the development of conventional and alternative extractive methods for the purification of agarose from seaweed. Separation Science and Technology, 53(3): 467-480. DOI:10.1080/01496395.2017.1394881
Chew K W, Show P L, Yap Y J, Juan J C, Phang S M, Ling T C, Chang J S. 2018b. Sonication and grinding pretreatments on Gelidium amansii seaweed for the extraction and characterization of agarose. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 12(4): 2.
Distantina S, Wiratni, Fahrurrozi M, Rochmadi. 2011. Carrageenan properties extracted from Eucheuma cottonii, Indonesia. World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology, 54(6): 738-742.
Duckworth M, Yaphe W. 1971. The structure of agar:part Ⅰ. Fractionation of a complex mixture of polysaccharides. Carbohydrate Research, 16(1): 189-197. DOI:10.1016/S0008-6215(00)86113-3
Fidelis G P, Camara R B G, Queiroz M F, Costa M S S P, Santos P C, Rocha H A O, Costa L S. 2014. Proteolysis, NaOH and ultrasound-enhanced extraction of anticoagulant and antioxidant sulfated polysaccharides from the edible seaweed, Gracilaria birdiae. Molecules, 19(11): 18 511-18 526. DOI:10.3390/molecules191118511
Francavilla M, Pineda A, Lin C S K, Franchi M, Trotta P, Romero A A, Luque R. 2013. Natural porous agar materials from macroalgae. Carbohydrate Polymers, 92(2): 1 555-1 560. DOI:10.1016/j.carbpol.2012.11.005
Fuse T, Goto F. 1971. Studies on utilization of agar. Agricultural and Biological Chemistry, 35(6): 799-804.
Gómez-Ordóñez E, Rupérez P. 2011. FTIR-ATR spectroscopy as a tool for polysaccharide identification in edible brown and red seaweeds. Food Hydrocolloids, 25(6): 1 514-1 520. DOI:10.1016/j.foodhyd.2011.02.009
Hernández-Carmona G, Freile-Pelegrín Y, Hernández-Garibay E. 2013. Conventional and alternative technologies for the extraction of algal polysaccharides. In: Domínguez H ed. Functional Ingredients from Algae for Foods and Nutraceuticals. Woodhead Publishing, Oxford, Philadelphia, p.476-515.
Kumar V, Fotedar R. 2009. Agar extraction process for Gracilaria cliftonii (Withell, Millar, & Kraft, 1994). Carbohydrate Polymers, 78(4): 813-819. DOI:10.1016/j.carbpol.2009.07.001
Li H Y, Yu X J, Jin Y, Zhang W, Liu Y L. 2008. Development of an eco-friendly agar extraction technique from the red seaweed Gracilaria lemaneiformis. Bioresource Technology, 99(8): 3 301-3 305. DOI:10.1016/j.biortech.2007.07.002
Loureiro R R, Reis R P, Critchley A T. 2010. In vitro cultivation of three Kappaphycus alvarezii (Rhodophyta, Areschougiaceae) variants (green, red and brown)exposed to a commercial extract of the brown alga Ascophyllum nodosum (Fucaceae, Ochrophyta). Journal of Applied Phycology, 22(1): 101-104. DOI:10.1007/s10811-009-9412-2
Mollet J C, Rahaoui A, Lemoine Y. 1998. Yield, chemical composition and gel strength of agarocolloids of Gracilaria gracilis, Gracilariopsis longissima and the newly reported Gracilaria cf.vermiculophylla from Roscoff (Brittany, France).. Journal of Applied Phycology, 10(1): 59-66. DOI:10.1023/A:1008051528443
Montaño N E, Villanueva R D, Romero J B. 1999. Chemical characteristics and gelling properties of agar from two Philippine Gracilaria spp. (Gracilariales, Rhodophyta). Journal of Applied Phycology, 11(1): 27-34. DOI:10.1023/A:1008084228609
Navarro D A, Flores M L, Stortz C A. 2007. Microwaveassisted desulfation of sulfated polysaccharides. Carbohydrate Polymers, 69(4): 742-747.
Nishinari K, Fang Y P. 2017. Relation between structure and rheological/thermal properties of agar.A mini-review on the effect of alkali treatment and the role of agaropectin. Food Structure, 13: 24-34. DOI:10.1016/j.foostr.2016.10.003
Orduña-Rojas J, García-Camacho K Y, Orozco-Meyer P, Ríosmena-Rodríguez R, Pacheco-Ruiz I, ZertucheGonzález J, Meling-López A E. 2008. Agar properties of two species of Gracilariaceae from the Gulf of California, Mexico. Journal of Applied Phycology, 20(2): 169-175. DOI:10.1007/s10811-007-9202-7
Ouyang Q Q, Hu Z, Li S D, Quan W Y, Wen L L, Yang Z M, Li P W. 2018. Thermal degradation of agar:mechanism and toxicity of products. Food Chemistry, 264: 277-283. DOI:10.1016/j.foodchem.2018.04.098
Oyieke H A. 1993. The yield, physical and chemical properties of agar gel from Gracilaria species (Gracilariales, Rhodophyta) of the Kenya coast. Hydrobiologia, 260-261(1): 613-620. DOI:10.1007/BF00049079
Recalde M P, Canelón D J, Compagnone R S, Matulewicz M C, Cerezo A S, Ciancia M. 2016. Carrageenan and agaran structures from the red seaweed Gymnogongrus tenuis. Carbohydrate Polymers, 136: 1 370-1 378. DOI:10.1016/j.carbpol.2015.10.007
Sasuga K, Yamanashi T, Nakayama S, Ono S, Mikami K. 2017. Optimization of yield and quality of agar polysaccharide isolated from the marine red macroalga Pyropia yezoensis. Algal Research, 26: 123-130. DOI:10.1016/j.algal.2017.07.010
Souza H K S, Sousa A M M, Gómez J, Gonçalves M P. 2012. Complexation of WPI and microwave-assisted extracted agars with different physicochemical properties. Carbohydrate Polymers, 89(4): 1 073-1 080.
Stanley N F. 1995. Agars. In: Stephen A M ed. Food Polysaccharides and Their Applications. Marcel Dekker Inc, New York. p.187-204.
Wang L J, Shen Z P, Mu H M, Lin Y, Zhang J L, Jiang X L. 2017. Impact of alkali pretreatment on yield, physicochemical and gelling properties of high quality agar from Gracilaria tenuistipitata. Food Hydrocolloids, 70: 356-362. DOI:10.1016/j.foodhyd.2016.11.042
Yarnpakdee S, Benjakul S, Kingwascharapong P. 2015. Physico-chemical and gel properties of agar from Gracilaria tenuistipitata from the lake of Songkhla, Thailand. Food Hydrocolloids, 51: 217-226. DOI:10.1016/j.foodhyd.2015.05.004